Utilitarianism is one of the most important and influential moral theories of modern times. Criticisms against ethical theories 8474 words bartleby. Criticism of utilitarianism by john stuart mill 895 words 4 pages. Julia markovits, associate professor, sage school of philosophy, cornell universtiy. In this wireless philosophy video, julia markovits cornell university gives an introduction to the moral theory of utilitarianism. Project muse nietzsches critique of utilitarianism. Rosss moral theory the next theory we will consider comes from william david ross 18771971 while mostly deontological, rosss theory is somewhat in between stricter deontological theories, like kants, and teleological theories, like utilitarianism. Introduction to philosophyutilitarianism wikibooks. But versions of these replies can also appeal to rule utilitarianism. Utilitarianism centers on the idea that whether actions are morally right or wrong depends on their outcomes.
He vacillates between social and individual pleasure. It is not possible to know whether all this are possible as it is. That is a book which contains an admirably clear and fair discussion of many ethical principles and methods. It becomes impossible to pass from individual to social good if selfishness and unselfishness are treated as mutually contradictory. In floating in the tank we are made in people, but rather open windows do is studied. Mill exposes not a few simple mistakes which are very likely to. Utilitarianism and its criticisms of utilitarianism bartleby.
Utilitarianism tells us that it is the happiness or well being of sentient beings that is the valuable thing. Since the utilitarian theory suggests pursuit of the greatest good, but does not discuss the equality inequality of distribution most common criticisms of utilitarianism of this happiness among individuals, it is widely criticized. Carritt says that it would be no commendation of an ethical theory if moral or even beneficial choice were. Utilitarianism, act and rule internet encyclopedia of. Utilitarianism is based on the notion that whatever functions should or should not be performed by the individual should be tested on the touchstone of utility.
Read online criticisms of utilitarianism umass book pdf free download link book now. An introduction to mills utilitarian ethics explicitly considered themselves utilitarians. Despite this, the theory has attracted copious criticism. Utilitarianism is the view that the right moral action is the one that maximizes happiness for all. Utilitarians hold the moral agent responsible for outcomes that are neither foreseeable nor controllable. Explain the objection that utilitarianism is a doctrine of expediency. Three different moral theories are briefly sketched.
Pdf critics of utilitarian principle of justice researchgate. His critique of characters and institutions is conveyed through irony and bitter sarcasm. Utilitarianism 9 formula should be correctly understood. Another criticism on utilitarian theory is the unequal distribution of happiness. This makes the ideals behind utilitarianism a mute point. We cant predict the future if you are judging your actions based on the outcome, then there is no way to make an accurate judgment. My purpose in this paper is to summarize some aspects of utilitarianism and to. Utility principle of justice belief in greater happiness of the greater number of the society. For example, suppose the government is planning to execute a person they know to be innocent for the purpose of setting an example. Lecture 12 utilitarianism and its critiques overview. I believe that the very imperfect notion ordinarily formed of its meaning, is the chief obstacle which impedes its reception. If we decide consequentialism utilitarianism is the right theory, then we may still debate what things are good happiness, etc.
The work from which our reading is taken, utilitarianism, deepens and strengthens the greatest happiness principle of jeremy bentham and his. Utilitarianism, by john stuart mill the selfdevelopment of the individual in his in. Variability of human experience differences between people. Jeremy benthams 17481832 principle of utility is open to the objection that it may well sacrifice the rights of the minority for the sake of the happiness of the majority. Shall i reply to this letter, file it, or make a paper dart out of it. Utilitarianism, groundwork to the metaphysics of morals.
For one thing, the criterion dispute includes a dispute about whether there is any such moral instinct. One of the oldest criticisms of utilitarianism is that it ignores our special obligations. In many respects, it is the outlook of scottish philosopher david hume 17111776 and his writings from the mid18th century. According to utilitarianism, such a natural action is immoral. For one thing, the criterion dispute includes a dispute about whether. Can utilitarianism account for justice and fairness. Utilitarianism is a family of consequentialist ethical theories that promotes actions that maximize happiness and wellbeing for the affected individuals.
Iv the standard criticisms of utilitarianism i describe these criticisms by considering how a sophisticated indirect decisionmaking utilitarian like hare could reply. Utilitarianism john stuart mill mcmaster faculty of. Phil 181 lecture 12 utilitarianism and its critiques. A criticism of john stuart mills utilitarianism, and the first problem with the theory that i shall be addressing, is his categorisation of higher and lower pleasures.
Utilitarianism and its critics edited with sn introduction by jonathan glover p, cm. Arguments against utilitarianism, origin and criticism. Originally, professor kuhn, professor feyerabend and dr lakatos were to be the main speakers, but for different reasons see below, p. Criticisms of utilitarianism intuitively speaking, utilitarianism appears to be an extremely attractive philosophy. Moreover, some authors criticize utilitarianism for. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of utilitarianism and what it means.
P1 if utilitarianism is true, the people in the cave should. One of the major criticisms of utilitarianism is that it fails to preserve human rights. In all of these fields, utilitarianism has its proponents and utilitarian arguments are common. An important aspect of rawlss argument is his attack on utilitarianism, which is the focus of this writeup rawls defines utilitarianism as fol. A utilitarian critique 493 one can effect a compromise between these welfarist theories, mixing the benefitmaximizing principle of utilitarianism with the equalizing principle of welfare egalitarianism. A critical analysis of utlitarianism oluwatosin adekanye a critical analysis of utilitarianism regardless of debate as to the origin of ethics are they innate or are they learned, are they god given.
Although different varieties of utilitarianism admit different characterizations, the basic idea behind all of them is to in some sense maximize utility, which is often defined in terms of wellbeing or related concepts. But both hold equally that morality must be deduced from principles. According to this theory, the value of an act is to be assessed on the basis of pleasure and pain. A theorem on utilitarianism eric maskin harvard university in a recent paper 1, daspremont and gevers establish that if a social welfare functional swfl satisfies several reasonable properties, and if interpersonal comparisons of absolute welfare levels are prohibited, although unit interpersonal comparisons of welfare are not. This document is available in its entirety in electronic format pdf on the national. Its important to be clear about what views williams argument, and the other arguments. Criticisms of utilitarianism umass pdf book manual.
Another fundamental criticism of utilitarianism is that it ignores justice. In being hooked to a machine we are motionless, our loveliness cannot be seen. Utilitarianism an introduction to the moral theories of jeremy bentham and john stuart mill. What utilitarianism is part 2 in john stuart mills utilitarianism. Oct 17, 2017 act utilitarianism is essentially benthams original formulation. Calculating or quantifying happiness or pleasure a problem 1. Ethics handout williams, a critique of utilitarianism. On a practical level, utilitarianism has been derided as unworkable, and even absurd.
A standard objection to utilitarianism is that it could require us to violate the standards of justice. Well, the biggest criticism of utilitarianism that comes to my mind is that it can be used to justify actions which may seem immoral by by general standards, such as killing 10 people to save 20 people. Utilitarianism but which states of affairs are valuable and which states of affairs are not. Ryders painism and his criticism of utilitarianism. Mar 24, 2016 the obvious criticism is that the greatest happiness of the greatest number of people described as the yardstick of utilitarianism might entail some egregious injustice on a minority or individual. One major criticism of utilitarianism is its potential conflict with the principle of justice. P1 if utilitarianism is true, then the execution of the homeless man was morally right. The basic idea then would then be to argue that if people follow rules that have the best consequences, they would not act in ways described in the objections. Because it is impossible to precisely quantify pleasure. Like other forms of consequentialism, its core idea is that whether actions are morally right or wrong depends on their effects. The original basis of this theory was hedonism, a psychological theory. Because pleasure is irrelevant to the rightness of an action. Finally, in section 5, i begin by staving off another alternative interpretation of nietzsches critique of utilitarianism, and then proceed to characterize nietzsches hostility toward english utilitarians as typifying his general suspicion of any attempt by a particular group to impose a single moral standard on all people. Download criticisms of utilitarianism umass book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf.
Traces of utilitarian thought can be found in the works of plato and aristotle, but not until the eighteenth century did utilitarianism truly begin to emerge as a welldefined and. Utilitarianism as an ethical theory journal of ethics in mental. It offers a simplicity that many other philosophical approaches lack and in particular cuts through the mish mash of moral rules favoured by deontological thinkers. Distastefulness, impossibility, impracticality, insufficiency. The project gutenberg ebook of utilitarianism, by john stuart. In chapter 2 of utilitarianism, mill says that some. A critical analysis of utlitarianism oluwatosin adekanye a critical analysis of utilitarianism regardless of debate as to the origin of ethics are they innate or are they learned, are they god given or are they manmade constructs the fact that ethics are invaluable to the human race remains uncontested.
In general, rule utilitarianism seems to involve two rather plausible intuitions. According to altruistic hedonism, universal or general happiness i. Utilitarianism s primary weakness has to do with justice. Fred feldman also offers the following criticisms of utilitarianism. Have a look at the strengths and weaknesses of utilitarianism bentham the hedonic calculus there are some circumstances when you can usefully use the calculus as a guide to determining the overall effects of a course of action, such as in choosing how to spend lottery money, or in deciding how to prioritise medical procedures in a hospital. I will argue that the utilitarian cannot overcome williams criticisms. As always, merely reading someone elses thoughts is the hardest way to develop your own thinking. It has been argued that there is no adequate means of defining happiness, nor any suitable method for quantifying levels of happiness. Criticisms of utilitarianism iv the standard criticisms. Criticisms of utilitarianism ocr religious studies. In the first place, rule utilitarians want to emphasize that moral rules are important. Hares brand of utilitarianism arose as a response to the criticism put forward. Individual acts are justified by being shown to be in accordance with correct moral rules.
Moore 39 i propose, then, to begin by an examination of mills utilitarianism. There now exists a diversity of critiques and alternatives to utilitarianism section 3. More specifically, the only effects of actions that are relevant are the good and bad results that they produce. Mill, utilitarianism 1863 a brief overview of the reading. John rawls was arguably the most important political philosopher of the twentieth century. Utilitarianism does not take into account rights and.
The file utilitarianism evaluates looks at key aspects of the theory, with positive and negative criticism of each point. We present the kernel and historical sources of ryders painist theory, and bring forward his main points or critique against utilitarianism. Utilitarianism takes no account of integrity the accidental act or one done with evil intent if promoting good ends is the good act. Then we discuss what we see as the major problems with ryders painism, in particular as compared to utilitarianism. Rule utilitarianism, on the other hand, holds that the rightness or wrongness of a particular action is. Professor james rachels critiqued the philosophy of utilitarianism, mainly by attacking the following points. Julia markovits cornell university gives an introduction to the moral theory of utilitarianism. According to hedonism, the main aim of life is the achievement of maximum pleasure. The obvious criticism is that the greatest happiness of the greatest number of people described as the yardstick of utilitarianism might entail some egregious injustice on a minority or individual. Mill exposes not a few simple mistakes which are very likely to be made by those who. On the one hand mill concedes mans natural yearning for pleasure, while on the other hand he makes utilitarianism the ultimate aim. It is important to understand utilitarianism as it forms the basic tenants of legal theory and function of laws. Since the utilitarian theory suggests pursuit of the greatest good, but does not discuss the equality inequality of distribution most common criticisms of utilitarianism of this happiness among individuals, it.
Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Waypers analysis of utilitarianism we find the following observation. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. Direct criticism of smarts text is largely confined to parts of section 6, where i have tried to show that a certain ambiguity in smarts defence of act utilitarianism, as against other sorts, arises from a deep difficulty in the whole subject. Because all that is required are the notions of more and less pleasure.
This file may be copied on the condition that the entire contents. Dickens hard times calls into question benthams theory. Criticisms of consequentialism 916 and 918 criticisms of. Utilitarianism is one of the best known and most influential moral theories. Peter singer is a contemporary philosopher whose basic approach to ethics is utilitarian. For example, if we were given the choice between saving two random people or our mother, most would choose to save their mothers.
It is extremely difficult to correctly determine what the exact consequences of your actions will be. This paper contends that their principal criticisms that utilitarianism is not a sound. The second half of the course will focus on interesting. This paper deals with ryders painism and his criticism of utilitarianism.
P1 if utilitarianism is true, then the doctors act of killing the janitor for his organs was morally right. The difference between these pleasures is founded on sort and not degree, therefore this makes comparison of the consequence of actions far more difficult to calculate. But it received both its name and its clearest statement in the writings of english philosophers jeremy bentham 17481832 and john stuart mill 18061873. Sep 12, 2014 in utilitarianism and integrity, bernard williams criticizes utilitarianism by introducing scenarios and speculating what utilitarianism might say about them, what we might say about utilitarianism, and what would be implied by certain ways of thinking about the scenarios. Dec 10, 2011 another criticism on utilitarian theory is the unequal distribution of happiness. What are some criticisms towards ethical utilitarianism. Dickenss hard times is a satire that exposes the flaws of the victorian society and its compliance with utilitarianism. W w there is nothing particularly wrong with research into cbw. Rather, the truest, most genuine, forms of utilitarianism provide the rational basis for the truest, most genuine, human rig. Utilitarianism in business can lead to a bottomline mentality in which decisions are based on achieving the greatest good for the organization as it pertains to the greatest number of stakeholders, including shareholders and all others affected by the actions of the organization the outcome is the determining factor, not the intent of the. John stuart mill 18061873, himself a utilitarian, sought to rescue utilitarianism from this.
Option 2 criticisms of utilitarianism john stuart mill was a 19th century influential philosopher and strong advocate of the moral theory, utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is the view that the right moral action is the. For act utilitarianism seems to imply that there cannot be such actions. Another criticism leveled against the utilitarian approach to punishment. Utilitarianism 7 as well as truth and falsehood, are questions of observation and experience. Utilitarianism john stuart mill mcmaster faculty of social. One of the major criticisms of utilitarianism is that it. Hedonic calculus is impossible to apply because pleasure is.
258 873 1366 1517 519 1050 1053 1 154 1561 636 354 347 1257 1227 1276 1421 947 505 712 1577 1277 354 207 583 1171 1217 552 1506 1399 1493 771 1349 929 1131 430 1321 892 1563 1350 1249 705 1286 983 49 66 1163 884 757 88